Call Sign reader Michael Lyons (Y52) was one of many drivers to be
caught on camera using the Islington bus lane and fined £40. In addition to
appealing, Michael also wrote to Robert Edwards of TfL's Street Management
team.
This is Mr Edwards' reply...
By Rob Edwards, Islington Borough Engineer, NC Area, TfL Street Management
Detection associated with pre-signals allows times operation to respond to
the proximity of a bus so as to minimise potential delays. This relies on
buses being able to reach the point of detection but the presence of other
traffic can prejudice this. Thus, from an operational viewpoint, TfL Street
Management generally seeks to exclude all motor vehicles except buses from
bus lanes that feed a pro-signal facility.
As you will be aware, the facility at The Angel was introduced
by the Traffic Director for London in 1997. The scheme involved the moving
of the central reserve in Upper Street to the west to allow the Duncan
Street to Liverpool Road part of the bus lane to be widened to double width
(keeping the same number of southbound lanes). The scheme also involved the
extension of the hours of operation of this bus lane to 24 hours and
installed a pre-signal at the end of the bus lane to allow buses to pass
through the Liverpool Road / Islington High Street / Upper Street junction
in advance of other southbound traffic. This particularly benefits buses
turning right into Pentonville Road. In order to achieve the desired bus
priority, the scheme required that only buses (and pedal cyclists) could use
the bus lane and pre-signal area. Accordingly all other traffic, including
taxis, were excluded from the bus lane, bus pre-signal and bus stops.
Surveys were carried out in 1997 and 1999 to determine the
impacts of the scheme.
|
WHY TAXIS CAN'T USE THE ISLINGTON BUS LANE
Usual sight, hold up for taxis whilst the bus lane is
empty
|
These surveys showed that the scheme has been successful in providing
significant southbound bus journey time savings without any delays to other
southbound traffic. Operations at bus stops have been significantly improved
with buses being able to access and leave stops unhindered.
When the scheme was introduced, objections to the exclusion of
taxis were received from the London Taxi Drivers Association. The decision
to proceed with the exclusion of taxis was made at that time. As complaints
have continued to be made from the taxi trade, a consultant's review was
undertaken last year. This recommended that the current exclusion of taxis
from the 24 hour southbound bus lane be retained for 3 main reasons.
- The number of taxis illegally using the bus lane and bus gate has
contributed to congestion between Liverpool Road and The Angel. This has
an adverse impact on bus operations.
- 80 buses an hour use this bus lane serving three bus stops, which
occupy approximately 73 metres of kerb length. The intrusion of other
vehicles within this kerb length can prevent buses reaching the kerb or
being aligned correctly to permit direct access onto the footway. It is
considered that permitting taxi access to drop off or pick up in this
area would have a clear adverse impact on bus operations.
|
- There is a tendency for pedestrians crossing from west to east to
cross during the "bus only" stage when the road is clear.
Whilst this behaviour is not encouraged, the risk associated with it is
considered to be relatively low taking into account the low speed of
buses leaving the stops and their visibility. Where taxis "cut
through" the bus lane and pre-signal, this risk to pedestrians is
considered to he significantly higher.
In response to the recent representations on this issue, a site meeting
was held on Friday 11th of July attended by Peter Brown, the Assistant
Director Street Management, Ed Thompson the Director of Taxis and Private
Hire and Tom Scullion and John Pace from the Society of Professional
Licensed Taxi Drivers. It is recognised that the current layout does cause
some difficulty for taxi operation, particularly in terms of pick-up and
set-down activity. Accordingly options to enhance facilities upstream and
downstream of the 24hour bus lane is being investigated and some alteration
to signage has been undertaken to aid clarity. However it is felt that to
avoid a significant issue in terms of pedestrian safety and promote the
maximum benefit to the large number of buses and bus passengers using this
facility, the
exclusion of taxis should remain.
Robert Edwards - TfL Street Management (North Central Area)
|