Alastair Hill arrived at DaC in 1996 and has played a part in the
most successful and profitable period that this Society has ever known.
Now he has decided to move on to new pastures and has written a final Call
Sign article on his views of our progress...
A report on my time at Dial-a-Cab, thoughts on its future, frank but
fair and anything negative balanced with positives; this was the request
from the Editor. In responding, I shall be unable to avoid getting
innocently entangled in the numerous, but generally trivial wrangles and
feuds which have beset and handicapped sections of the taxi trade for
years. This will undoubtedly inflame some, but I hope others will view my
comments as personal and constructive and nothing more sinister.
The first comment must be to commend the quality and
professionalism of 'Call Sign'. Without its existence, it would be
impossible even to communicate in this manner at all. Despite what some
critics might say, it is not the mouthpiece of the management and in
contrast to some other trade publications, is not dedicated to boosting
already inflated egos. As long as public decency is not offended, a full
range of opinions and comments is allowed and whilst some make poor
reading, most are constructive and relevant and have allowed many
excellent ideas to be discussed. Well done to all those who over the years
have contributed to building this magazine.
During My Time at Dial-a-Cab
My time at DaC has been eventful, much of it good and some not
so good but the latter generally quickly forgotten. Since many of the
events have involved me, I hope I have contributed in some small way to
DaC's present high standing in the trade and to its financial strength.
Friendly Societies need financial security just as much as most other
organisations and here DaC's record is unparalleled:
In the last 4 years Computer Cab lost a net £1.08m, RTL made £769k
and DaC made £4.2m.*
We must therefore have been doing a lot more things right than the
others. This has benefited members, most tangibly through the static or
falling subscriptions of the last 5 years and credit for this is due to
businesslike
|
management. This major success story has not gone unnoticed by the world at
large.
I foresee the Society's value continuing to increase more slowly
in the future. The major MDC renewal programme will reduce surpluses over the
next 2-4 years but disasters apart, there should be no risk to the Society's
independence or viability.
There are always discussions about where DaC should be going and
my own view is quite clear; unless the members adopt different Rules and
objects, then the only requirement for the Society is to devote itself to
obtaining radio bookings for members. There is no authority to have commercial
ambitions beyond that; whether they are to offer cars or other travel services
to customers, to accumulate surpluses beyond those needed to renew assets, or
to merge, float or find 'strategic partners', whatever they are and whatever
their purpose is in this industry.
I personally find this limitation on commercial objectives
somewhat disappointing, since I believe the Society has the potential to
achieve its existing purposes in happy combination with other commercial
activities where its expertise could further increase the value to members.
The Structure of Management
However, for this to be accomplished and for members to realise the
full benefits, the Society would need to take on a different management
structure and to be converted to an equity-based ownership structure with a
focus on profit-making and sharing. This would require the appointment of 2-3
full-time business managers to take over some of the executive duties
traditionally performed by the elected Board. Recruitment for these positions
and based on merit, would be either from existing resources or from outside. It
would also require the Society to convert to a plc by exchanging the membership
shares for equity shares, each bearing a proportionate value of the business.
As many will remember, when
|
this was proposed back in 1997 insufficient members voted for it and
before scaremongers get to work, the Board have since stated they will not
revive the issue unless directed to by the members. This means that
the value of the business will remain beyond the reach of those who have
built it up, perhaps a missed opportunity or perhaps a decision truly
reflecting the altruistic nature of the members who wish the Society to
continue to reflect the non-profit-making motives of the Friendly Society
movement.
For the future, therefore, I see the Society doing next year what it did
last year with little change apart from using ever-improving technology.
However, services focused on customer preferences will become
of increasing importance and prosperity in the coming years may well depend
on the radio taxi trade sacrificing some cherished practices in order to
maintain a strong position in a changing market place where new competition
and political directives could have unwanted consequences.
And Finally...
On a lighter note, memorable experiences include encountering a
driver who believed passionately that the Society should have bought up all
the major London hotels years ago in order to secure the airport work they
generate for DaC drivers! Needless to say there was no mention of how they
were to be paid for or the small problem of actually running the hotels once
they had been purchased! And what is so good about the airport anyway...?
Another driver was convinced that since we make surpluses but
don't have the equivalent in the bank, that the funds are being salted away
somewhere for the benefit of the Board and with the tacit approval of the
auditors; what a great idea!
To conclude, I must express my thanks to colleagues on the
Board, to staff and to the drivers I have met for the interesting times I
have experienced at Dial-a-Cab. It certainly is a unique organisation and
gives more surprises than most. I wish the whole organisation every success
for the future!
*Based on published accounts
Alastair Hill
Good luck for the future Alastair, from all at Call
Sign...Ed
|